Conference Paper 28 January 2027

Reflexive Structurative Curation: Towards a FAIR Chance for African Scholarship through Critical Action and Intervention

Abstract

When research data for African scholarship are curated, standard subject and genre vocabularies (such as LCSH, MARC genre lists, and global knowledge graphs) often lack or distort concepts and resource formations – genres, collections, and related assemblages – originating from African scholarship. This creates a structural double bind: resources are either reframed, unintentionally or unreflectively, into Eurocentric categories that flatten their meaning, or left weakly indexed and marginal in global discovery. Drawing on Bourdieu’s concepts of field and capital, we treat the scholarly information environment as a non-neutral discursive, social, and political space. Here, metadata annotations are forms of capital; their collation brings forth a resource as a discursive agent with its own intentionality (direction) and effect (positioning). Critiques of global knowledge production show African scholarship treated as a repository for raw data (Gondwe 2022) or boxed into so-called local expertise beneath unmarked universal Experts who set the frame narratives (Musariri et al. 2024). In metadata infrastructures, these critiques surface as debates over data sovereignty, extractivism, language use, and unintentional reframing, which sit at the intersection of standardisation, trust, and power.

To address this double bind, we propose reflexive structurative curation. Building on structuration theory (Giddens 1984; Orlikowski 2000), we argue that metadata schemas act as hidden structuration frames, so strategic curation is needed to give resources a fair chance, telling a just, descriptive story of each from its own epistemic locus while positioning it to restructure global knowledge. Foregrounding uniqueness, origin, and provenance counters invisibility and misrepresentation, but an exclusive focus on particularity risks the creation of isolated information islands. Reflexive structurative curation therefore holds CARE and FAIR in productive tension – honouring specificity without creating such islands – across three dimensions: Standardisation (Signification) through localised schemas and authorities; Trust (Legitimation) through CARE and Local Contexts protocols; and Power (Domination) through the positioning of African research entities as equal-weight authority nodes.

Methodologically, the study is guided by Spies and Seesemann’s (2016) pluralicity and relationality, which approach African lifeworlds as multiple, constituted, and interconnected rather than flattened or isolated, and by participatory resource curation, which replaces one-way extraction and participation-washing with cyclical co-design and normative governance (Sheppard et al. 2026). Within the metadata redesign of a Digital Research Environment for the Africa Multiple cluster, we conduct critical action research as a three-stage discursive intervention: (1) a critical audit of web ontologies and controlled vocabularies; (2) constructive schema praxis developing localised Linked Open Data, local authority files, and Local Contexts protocols; and (3) iterative focus groups with curators, librarians, and data stewards across African partner institutions. Throughout, we critically examine curatorial habitus, the embodied schemes of classification that make dominant metadata schemas and annotation practices feel technically neutral. The focus groups assess local validity (epistemic and linguistic fidelity, provenance, and CARE governance); perceived global validity (FAIR interoperability and equal-weight authority in global graphs, alongside technical checks); and perceived changes in curatorial practice. Together, these stages examine whether and how strategic curation can support relational sovereignty without sacrificing global connectivity.